Skip to content

Defective Goods and Notice Requirements Under the CISG

· ≈3 min read · Corporate

What buyers and sellers should know about inspection, non-conformity notices, defective goods and evidence in CISG disputes involving Türkiye.

i. Direct answer

In CISG sales disputes, a buyer who receives defective goods must usually examine the goods and notify the seller of the non-conformity within the required time. Failure to give proper notice may cause the buyer to lose remedies even where the goods were genuinely defective.

Non-conformity means the goods do not meet the contract requirements, including quality, quantity, description, packaging or fitness for purpose. The CISG links buyer remedies to timely examination and notice.

CISG Articles 35 to 44 are central. Article 35 defines conformity. Article 38 requires examination within as short a period as practicable. Article 39 requires notice specifying the nature of non-conformity within a reasonable time. Turkish procedural law may govern evidence and litigation in Turkish courts.

iv. Verified court and appellate practice

Courts and tribunals examine timing, content and proof of notice. A complaint that merely says 'goods are bad' may be insufficient. The buyer should specify the defect, quantity affected, inspection result and remedy sought. This section deliberately avoids invented case numbers. Where a case-specific filing relies on precedent, the relevant Court of Cassation, regional appellate court or Constitutional Court materials should be checked against the current file and date of publication.

v. Doctrine and practical debate

The practical debate concerns what counts as a reasonable time. This depends on the goods, industry, defect type, transport, inspection possibility and communications between the parties. Perishable goods and obvious defects usually require faster action.

vi. Conditions for application or proceedings

The buyer must show that the goods were non-conforming and that notice was given properly and timely. The seller may argue late notice, vague notice, misuse, transport damage or acceptance.

vii. Time limits and when they start

There is no single universal number of days for every CISG notice. Article 39 uses a reasonable-time standard, with a two-year long-stop rule unless inconsistent with a contractual guarantee. Contractual inspection clauses may add stricter requirements.

viii. Competent court or authority

The dispute may be heard by the chosen court or arbitral tribunal. If Turkish courts hear the matter, evidence rules and expert examination under Turkish procedure may be decisive.

ix. Burden of proof, evidence and procedural issues

Key evidence includes inspection reports, photos, samples, laboratory analysis, transport records, warehouse records, notices, e-mails, expert reports and records showing when the buyer discovered or should have discovered the defect.

x. Practical points for real cases

The buyer should preserve the goods and evidence. The seller should ask immediately for inspection details, samples and proof of timing. Both sides should avoid informal statements that later weaken their position.

xi. Common mistakes

Common mistakes include late complaint, vague complaint, destroying or reselling defective goods without evidence, failing to separate transport damage from manufacturing defect and ignoring contractual notice clauses.

xii. Frequently asked questions

Does the buyer always lose rights if notice is late?

Late notice can seriously limit remedies, but the facts and CISG exceptions must be assessed.

Is oral notice enough?

It may create proof problems. Written notice is safer.

Can Turkish law replace CISG notice rules?

Not where the CISG governs the issue, unless the Convention is excluded or a gap exists.

xiii. Experienced lawyer assessment

Many CISG defect cases are won or lost on notice. The factual defect matters, but timing and specificity often matter just as much.

xiv. Günser + Partners note

The correct legal route in these matters must be determined by reference to the date of the events, the legal position of the parties, the available evidence and the applicable statutory deadlines. Missing a deadline, applying to the wrong authority or presenting evidence in the wrong procedural form may cause loss of rights. You may contact Günser + Partners for an assessment of your matter under current Turkish legislation and court practice.

We can assess your legal situation together

You can convey your matter directly to our attorneys by telephone, e-mail or WhatsApp. Your application is carefully assessed according to the nature of the case.

Copyright & Use

The copyright in all articles and content on this website belongs to Günser + Partners (Law & Consultancy). If any content is copied or summarised and published on other websites without permission, civil and criminal proceedings will be initiated. Fellow lawyers are free to use the content of the articles in their court submissions.

Legal Information & Disclaimer

This article has been prepared solely for general legal information; it does not constitute legal advice or an opinion on any specific case. Each dispute must be assessed separately in light of its own circumstances, time limits, evidence and the legislation in force. Acting in reliance on this content may result in a loss of rights. Reading this article or contacting us does not, by itself, create an attorney–client relationship.

Call